The source itself is balanced and considers the context of the battle, making it trustworthy Also, Haig was not as unimaginative with his tactics as many think.
How to Write a Summary of an Article? Did General Haig deserve to be the Butcher of the Somme?
It took place on either side of the River Somme in France, and it ended on 18 November The battle caused millions of deaths and injuries between both sides.
From a great adventure, to a bloody event. General Douglas Haig was one of the commanders from the British army in the Battle of Somme, the battle with one of the highest casualties in British military history.
But does he deserve the title? Or was he just doing his job and was there any misunderstanding in the battle? I will talk about the evidences and explain why many people view both sides and if he deserves the title or not.
South bank of the German defense was made incapable of resisting another attack. They retreated to the north bank which abandonment of Fricourt was ordered.
The German army went to the north bank and inflicted a huge defeat on the British infantry, which killed so many Britain soldiers. A lot of people called Douglas Haig the Butcher of the Somme. Here are some pieces of evidence to support this point of view.
It also tells us that General Haig received a large amount of money and an Earl given by the loyal afterward. This source was written years after the war How far did general haig deserve a local newspaper called Pro Venanic.
Did General Haig deserve to be the Butcher of the Somme? 1 July , Battle of Somme started, fought by the armies of the British and French empires against the German Empire. It took place on either side of the River Somme in France, and it ended on 18 November General Douglas Haig was one of the commanders from the British army in the Battle of Somme, the battle with one of the highest casualties in British military history. Some people called him “Butcher Haig” or “Butcher of the Somme” after his death in , because he sent thousands of British soldiers to their death. General Haig was asked to relieve pressure of the French by French commanders. Therefore there was no choice but an offensive somewhere on the Western Front by the British army. I believe General Haig did deserve to be named Butcher of the Somme for several reasons.
It can be trusted because it was written by a person who was in the battle who experienced what the war was like and what Haig was doing. Although the Germans had lostmen during the war and had retreated 10 kilometers back from their trenches.
They human cost of the Britain and French were also very high. Especially on the first day of the battle, which lost a massive number of casualties in the war history?
Which made the people bitter and angry especially the anger from the men in the Front line, seeing Haig standing kilometers behind them, thinking that he was being a coward, and the ones who lost their family and relatives on the 1st of July?
Smith was also a private in the 1st Border regiment fighting on the Somme. He was one of them who called Haig a Butcher. Douglas Haig should have been hung, drawn and quartered for what he did on the Somme.
The cream of the British manhood was shattered in less than six hours. He wrote this on Julywhich was the first month of the battle of the Somme. Given that over 50 thousands soldiers died on the first day, Haig as the leader of the team, P. The source supports the point that Douglas Haig is the Butcher of the battle of the Somme.
He was not endowed with any of the elements of imagination and vision… And he certainly had none of that personal magnetism which has enabled great leaders of men to inspire multitudes with courage, faith and a spirit of sacrifice… He was incapable of planning vast campaigns on the scale demanded on so immense a battlefield.
This source is reliable because given the fact that it was written by a Prime Minister of Britain during WW1. There are three essential differences: Now turning to the Regimental Sergeant- Major what is the second difference?
This source is very useful for us knowing more about General Haig at the time, in the cartoon, the major general is addressing the men before an attack behind the lines. This is also reliable, because it was written inwhich was after the battle of the Somme.
And it gives out information about Haig and his team. However stupid they might have been, however much they were the product of a system which obstructed enterprise, they knew what they were doing.
There can never be forgiven. So this source can be either reliable or not and it might not be so fair to Haig saying that he is a butcher.
On the other hand, the second interpretation is that Haig was just doing his job as a general. Different people have their different evidences for that. But no one cared to make a legend out of that. This might be supporting the point that he was just doing his job and he made a great success in the war.We will write a custom essay sample on The First World War – Field Marshall Haig: The Butcher of the Somme?
specifically for you for only $ $/page. Lloyd-George also says that ‘I expressed my doubts to General Haig ’ about this strategy. How Far Did General Haig Deserve to Be Known as Butcher of the Somme ;.
Feild Marshall Haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of December , he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career. Haig decided to attack the Germans at the river Somme in to attract German soldiers from the town of Verdun where they were fighting the French and had almost broken through.
Does General Haig Deserve to Be Remembered 'The Butcher of the Somme'? Words | 6 Pages Douglas Haig (19 June – 29 January ) was a senior commander in the First World War (WWI), and perhaps one of the most notable figures in British Military history.
Douglas Haig was born in Edinburgh on 19 June into a wealthy family who owned a whisky business. He studied at Oxford University and in went to the Royal Military Academy at Sandhurst.
Nov 10, · General Haig was the general that led the attacks in the Battle of Somme. After the war, he was bitterly criticized for underestimating the Germans and people gave him the name "Butcher of Somme". Just looking for opinions and plz support with heartoftexashop.com: Resolved. In , Haig went to the War Office as director of military training.
His responsibilities included the organisation of a British Expeditionary Force (BEF) for deployment in the event of war with Germany. On the outbreak of war in , Haig was commanding the BEF's 1st Army Corps, whose overall commander was Sir John French.